Topchubashov Center
Report 1 min read

From displacement to repatriation: is there a right of return?

From displacement to repatriation: is there a right of return?
Javid Rahimli Alumnus Published

Listen to this article Read by an AI voice

This research examines the legal status of the right of return for forcibly displaced persons under international law, arguing that it has become a norm of customary international law (CIL). Through analysis of treaties, declarations, resolutions, and case law, the research explores the legal foundations and challenges of enforcing this right, emphasizing its critical role in addressing global displacement crises.

The study identifies inconsistencies in how the right of return is applied across instruments like the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights and the Geneva Conventions. Key questions include: Who qualifies? When is it binding? What limitations are permissible? While some frameworks broaden protections to generational refugees, others restrict them, reflecting the lack of a unified approach.

A significant finding is that the right of return was not fully recognized as CIL until the 1990s, despite earlier references in international law. Historical examples, such as repatriation in Bosnia and Rwanda, highlight both the potential for and obstacles to implementing this right, including legal, economic, and security challenges.

The study calls for stronger legal frameworks, including a new UN Human Rights Committee general comment on ICCPR Article 12(4) and an additional protocol to the 1951 Refugee Convention, to clarify protections and address modern challenges. It argues that proportionality in limiting this right diminishes across generations, with stronger claims for those directly displaced.

The research stresses the urgent need for a globally recognized legal structure to consistently enforce the right of return, balancing state sovereignty with displaced persons’ rights. As displacement crises escalate, establishing clear legal mechanisms is essential to protect individuals, support repatriation, and uphold international law’s credibility.

Download the full report.

Related work

Report

The “STANS” Stranded - Central Asian States Race to the Sea

Central Asia is increasingly caught between wars and economic sanctions in neighbouring countries. These disruptions have constrained established trade routes, forcing the region to improvise and rely more heavily on alternative corridors. Yet many alternative...

Khagani Gasimov, 23 October 2026

Report

Ukraine's Defense Industry, Military Innovation, and Strategic Integration

One of the defining characteristics of Ukraine's defense-industrial transformation has been the restructuring of military procurement mechanisms. Conventional defense procurement systems are generally designed for peacetime environments, emphasizing lengthy pl...

Aslan Hasanli, 13 October 2026

Report

Abkhazia as Russia Security Multiplier on the Black Sea

Among all the post-Soviet de facto entities arising from the USSR's secessionist conflicts, Abkhazia stands out as one of the most developed and multidimensional cases of patron-client relationships and dependency. Since unilaterally declaring independence fro...

Alberto Carrer, 30 June 2026

Report

Azerbaijani Foreign Policy in 2025: Key Highlights

The year 2025 marked a period of adjustment and consolidation in Azerbaijan’s foreign policy. From its immediate vicinity to neighboring regions, Baku approached its external environment not as a challenge to be reacted to, but as an emerging architecture to b...

Rusif Huseynov, Murad Muradov, Simona Scotti, Mahammad Mammadov, Gulkhanim Mammadova, 24 December 2025