Topchubashov Center
Expert opinion 3 min read

Kocharyan-style omnibalancing may cost Armenia its already beleaguered sovereignty

Kocharyan-style omnibalancing may cost Armenia its already beleaguered sovereignty
Mahammad Mammadov Research Fellow Published

Listen to this article Read by an AI voice

In more than a year’s time since Armenia’s defeat in the Second Karabakh War, it is already a well-established fact that Yerevan’s dependence on Russia has reached unprecedented levels and no serious political force in Armenian politics questions the future of the country’s alliance with Russia. Recently there have been calls for further integration with Russia, similar to the Russia-Belarus Union State, that will likely push Armenia deeper into Moscow’s orbit. In an interview with Russian state-owned media outlet Sputnik on February 8, Armenia’s former president and head of the opposition Hayastan alliance Robert Kocharyan said Yerevan should very seriously think about much deeper interaction with Russia, possibly a full-fledged modern integration. Later, in a February 17 press conference, he claimed Armenia should not be afraid of joining the Union State and pragmatically calculate the costs and benefits of such a choice.   

Kocharyan’s musings about the Union State with Russia are part of a classic omnibalancing strategy where local elites seek engagement with external powers to ensure their political and physical survival that sometimes comes at the expense of the interests of the state. So his political maneuvering entails appeasing lesser threats - that is loss of sovereignty to a Russia-led supranational state - to address more pressing challenges in the domestic and external arena. Posing himself as the most pro-Russian pole in Armenian politics, he aims to create fractures in the incumbent regime’s ties with Moscow and guarantee Russia’s backing for his return to power to consolidate authoritarian rule in the country. In this context, it should come as no surprise that he accuses Pashinyan’s government of moving Armenia from Russia’s sphere of influence to a Turkish one and promises Russia a strong ally in the South Caucasus presumably under his rule.

Armenia’s continuing negotiations with Turkey on the normalization of relations and its openness to gradual reconciliation with Azerbaijan is deleterious to Kocharyan’s policy agenda that succumbs to a monumentally self-destructive ideological fever of Turkophobia. Expectedly, he exaggerates the challenges Armenia could face after the opening of borders with Turkey and construction of railroads connecting Baku to Ankara, hence reigniting ordinary Armenians’ long-held beliefs that these two neighbouring countries are natural enemies and Armenia needs a strong leader with Russia’s support to overcome this challenge. In a union state with Russia, he believes he can neutralize his political rivals, thus putting an end to Armenia’s half-hearted transition to democracy, and in the long term, return some territories in Karabakh Yerevan lost in the 44-day war in 2020. Such a scenario bodes well neither for Armenia’s existence as an independent state nor multilateral peace-making efforts in the region. 

What makes Kocharyan’s comment on the possibility of joining the Union State more interesting is it has come on the heels of similar moves recently taken by leaders of some member states of the Eurasian Economic Union. In Belarus, after years of playing the West against mounting Russian pressure, last year president Lukashenko acceded to Vladimir Putin’s demands with regard to the “creation” of the Union State to get Moscow’s support to crack down domestic protests and balance ideological and economic challenges emanating from the West. According to Lukashenko, Russia has rolled up her sleeves to create a mini Soviet Union of sorts that will include not only Russia and Belarus but also Central Asian republics, Ukraine, and Armenia who “has nowhere else to go”. In Kazakhstan, president Tokayev’s invitation of Russia-led CSTO troops to the country to clamp down on anti-government protests and intra-elite struggle in early January also showed how local elites opt for compromising state sovereignty to strengthen their hand against primary threats in domestic politics. Kocharyan is playing along similar lines that he hopes might open his way to power and guarantee Russian help against 2018-like revolutions at the expense of Armenian sovereignty and peace in the South Caucasus.  

 

Related work

Expert opinion

US foreign policy before midterm election

As the US midterm election is approaching, the correlation between President Trump’s statements and actual US policies, gets more and more uncertain. And while his occasional eccentricities on Twitter or during rallies with supporters, have become part of a po...

Murad Muradov, 27 October 2026

Expert opinion

Connecting Central Asia and the South Caucasus

On November 15, Azerbaijan formally joined the Central Asian Consultative Meetings, expanding what was known as the Central Asian Five (C5) into a Central Asian Six (C6). Many in Central Asia find it surprising. But when viewed through the lens of recent geopo...

Gulkhanim Mammadova, 1 December 2025

Expert opinion

Azerbaijan joins the C5: implications for Eurasian regional architecture

When the long-standing C5 format of Central Asian cooperation formally expanded into a C6 on 15 November in Tashkent, Azerbaijan’s accession was framed as a natural extension of historical and linguistic affinities. Yet behind the rhetoric lies a structural tr...

Gulkhanim Mammadova, 21 November 2025

Expert opinion

Kazakhstan joins the Abraham Accords: Pragmatism or Symbolism?

Kazakhstan’s accession to the Abraham Accords—anticipated in some political circles—may still raise eyebrows. Unlike the original signatories, who were establishing relations with Israel from scratch, Kazakhstan has long maintained cordial ties with the Jewish...

Rusif Huseynov, 9 November 2025

Expert opinion

13 June attack: quick comments

In the most extensive attack on Iran since the country’s 1980-88 war with Iraq, Israeli forces have launched multiple waves of nationwide bombings. The attack is ongoing and believed to be the opening shots of a wider campaign to degrade Iran’s military comman...

Murad Muradov, 13 June 2025

Expert opinion

Historic First in Tbilisi: Armenia, Azerbaijan and Georgia trilateral talks

On April 17, Tbilisi hosted the first-ever formal trilateral meeting between the foreign ministries of Armenia, Azerbaijan and Georgia. According to official statements, the primary aim of the meeting was to create a platform for open dialogue and to explore p...

Gulkhanim Mammadova, 17 April 2025

Expert opinion

Munich speech, 18 years later

The Munich speech of the U.S. Vice President J. D. Vance will definitely enter the textbooks of the future as one of the harbingers of a new historic period. This speech has been arguably more shocking than Vladimir Putin’s diatribe he made on the same stage 1...

Murad Muradov, 19 February 2025